Why Do Some Believe Firefighters Are Lousy Ambulance Drivers?
When I heard some EMTs discussing why firemen are considered lousy ambulance drivers, it sparked a thought-provoking debate. Here’s an analysis of the reasons behind this perception and why it might be more nuanced than it appears.
Vehicle Differences: Fire Engines vs Ambulances
In my work environment, firefighters are not allowed to drive ambulances, and vice versa for EMTs and fire engines. Different vehicles require different driving techniques and handling. Fire engines are designed for transporting water and hoses to firefighting scenes, while ambulances are designed for transporting medical equipment and patients. Driving an ambulance requires a unique mindset and training, especially when compared to the fast-paced environment of a fire engine.
When firefighters are responding to a fire, they prioritize speed and safety. The goal is to arrive at the scene quickly without compromising safety. In contrast, an ambulance requires a more cautious approach. The driver must navigate without causing further injury to the patient or risking the physical integrity of the crew. Improper driving can worsen the patient’s condition or injure the provider in the back, complicating the treatment process.
Training and Certification
Many modern fire departments mandate that all their personnel obtain at least EMT certification, regardless of whether they operate an ambulance service. Firefighters with EMT certification gradually learn how to drive an ambulance, sometimes after receiving harsh criticism from medics in the back. These instances highlight the importance of proper training and experience, but they can also arise naturally from the dynamics within the team.
In some departments that do transport, private ambulances or separate municipal services often handle the transfers. When a call is critical, requiring both crew members to attend to the patient, fire companies often ask a firefighter to drive the ambulance, even though they might not be EMTs. The less senior firefighters are more likely to be chosen for driving, which can lead to less experience and training in this specialized field.
Misconceptions and Human Nature
Somewhat ironic, the perception that firefighters are lousy ambulance drivers can be a result of human nature, not just a lack of training. Friendly rivalries and resentment can play a role, especially in departments where firefighters earn higher wages, benefits, and status. It’s important to remember that many ambulance personnel are not actively aspiring to become firefighters; they simply want to serve their communities in a different capacity.
Ultimately, whether a firefighter can handle driving an ambulance depends on their training, experience, and the dynamics of their team. These elements can be influenced by numerous factors, including the nature of the department, the specialization of the personnel, and the individual skills and mindset required for each vehicle type.
Understanding the nuances behind the perception of firefighters as lousy ambulance drivers involves recognizing the different training and techniques required for each role, as well as the complexities of human interactions within emergency services.