Consequences of a Soldier’s Decision to Hide on the Battlefield
It's a scenario every soldier aims to avoid: being in a combat situation where the only path to survival seems to be hiding. However, as the story of my dad in February 1945 illustrates, this decision can have far-reaching consequences. In this article, we explore the immediate and long-term impacts of a soldier choosing to hide on the battlefield.
Immediate Safety: A False Sense of Security
Firstly, a soldier might think that hiding provides immediate safety. Finding cover or concealment can indeed offer a temporary reprieve from enemy fire, giving them a breathing space to avoid immediate danger. Yet, such a strategy often comes with its own set of risks.
Risk of Isolation: A Double-Edged Sword
While the immediate danger may be averted, hiding can lead to isolation from the unit. This can be particularly dangerous if the unit is forced to retreat, with the soldier potentially left behind or captured. Even if the unit remains stable, the soldier risks becoming a liability by not being able to contribute to the mission.
Impact on Morale: A Team’s Victory is Its Members’
The act of hiding can also significantly impact morale. If other soldiers see their comrade hiding, it may be perceived as cowardly behavior, leading to a breakdown in trust and cohesion within the team. This can have a detrimental effect on the overall effectiveness of the unit and can erode the sense of unity that is crucial in combat.
Command Response: Rules and Consequences
Military protocol places a high value on unit cohesion and following orders. If a soldier hides without authorization, they can face severe disciplinary action. Depending on the military’s rules of engagement and conduct, the soldier might face reprimands, charges, or even more serious consequences.
Potential for Combat Effectiveness: A Collaborative Effort
Furthermore, hiding might prioritize personal safety over the collective good. Soldiers are trained to engage the enemy and fulfill their roles. By staying hidden, the soldier compromises the overall effectiveness of the unit, potentially leading to a compromised mission or increased risk for others on the team.
Long-Term Consequences: Impacts Beyond the Battlefield
Even if the immediate situation is resolved in one's favor, hiding can have long-term consequences. If discovered after the hiding, the soldier may face reprimands or more severe disciplinary action. The psychological impact can take a toll, affecting future deployments and possibly career advancement.
Father's Perspective: The Dilemma of Survival
My dad, speaking in February 1945 when the war in Europe was just over 70 days from its end, emphasizes a sense of pragmatism and survival. Having experienced the horrors of North Africa, Sicily, and the relentless fighting around Caen, he urges caution and discipline. 'So far so good. Nearly there. Don’t be stupid,' he warns, highlighting the importance of maintaining composure and adherence to duty.
Conclusion
While hiding might seem like a straightforward solution to immediate danger, it carries significant long-term risks. From the immediate safety of the soldier to the broader implications for unit morale and military discipline, the decision to hide can have far-reaching effects. It is crucial for soldiers to make informed and strategic decisions, prioritizing not only their own safety but also the collective success of their unit.