Choosing Between Rekeying and Lock Changes: A Comprehensive Guide
When faced with the decision of whether to rekey or change locks, several factors come into play. The choice ultimately depends on your specific situation, budget, and security needs. This guide explores the pros and cons of each option and provides insights to help you make an informed decision.
Cost Considerations
One of the primary factors when deciding between rekeying and changing locks is the cost involved. Rekeying is often less expensive, particularly if you need to update multiple locks. Changing locks, on the other hand, can be more costly, especially when new hardware is required. However, the long-term cost-effectiveness may depend on the frequency of lock changes or rekeying.
Security Implications
Security is a critical concern, especially for properties that require high levels of protection. Changing locks provides complete control over who has access to your property. When you rekey, there is a possibility that someone may have a copy of the old key, potentially compromising your security. Professional locksmiths recommend changing locks when dealing with high-value or critical security situations to ensure absolute control and peace of mind.
Convenience and Disruption
Convenience is another important factor to consider. Rekeying is generally a faster process than changing locks, making it a more efficient option, particularly if you have multiple locks to update. Changing locks can be time-consuming and may cause inconvenience, especially if services are disrupted during the transition. For establishments like businesses with multiple keys, changing locks can be particularly disruptive.
Compatibility and Aesthetics
Compatibility and aesthetic considerations should not be overlooked. If you are satisfied with the existing hardware and want to maintain a consistent look, rekeying is often the better option. Changing locks may require new hardware that may not be compatible with your existing doors, leading to additional costs and potential installation challenges. This is especially true for vintage or antique properties where aesthetic continuity is important.
Professional Recommendations
Ultimately, the decision between rekeying and changing locks depends on your priorities and needs. If in doubt, consulting with a professional locksmith can provide valuable insights and personalized recommendations based on your specific situation.
For instance, in the UK, many locksmiths prefer changing locks over rekeying. A professional locksmith shares their experience, stating, 'In my ten years, I have had a handful of recalls where the issue was always caused by a customer getting poor-quality key copies. However, if a problem arises, it is crucial to show proof of the cause to avoid blame.' This illustrates the importance of maintaining high-quality standards when dealing with locks.
Additionally, the type of lock can significantly impact the decision. Most modern locks, such as euro cylinders or rim nightlatches, are relatively inexpensive and easy to change. However, for unusual, antique, or high-security locks, rekeying may be a better option. For example, a Chubb 3J60 lock, which costs ￡140 new, is worth rekeying in an hour, even if it involves generating only a few new keys. The cost and effort of replacing such a lock are often outweighed by the labor of rekeying.
By carefully considering these factors and consulting with a professional locksmith, you can make an informed decision that best meets your needs and ensures the security and functionality of your property.